Aggregated scores of NS-rated games

All scores ordered by number.


Gears of War 2 - 9.6
(GC) Metroid Prime - 9.5
(N64) Banjo-Tooie - 9.5
(SNES)Yoshi's Island - 9.5
Fallout 3 - 9.5
Fable II - 9.4
(XBLA) Street Fighter II HD - 9.3
Resident Evil 5 - 9.2
Dead Space - 9.0
Elite Beat Agents - 9.0
Kirby Super Star Ultra - 9.0

Call of Duty 5 - 8.8
Age Of Empires: Mythologies - 8.5
Animal Crossing - 8.5
Deadly Creatures - 8.0
Dark Sector - 8.0
The Darkness - 8.0
Professor Layton CV - 8.0


Pokemon Mystery Dungeon - 7.5

(Ware) My Pokemon Ranch - 3.0

Good, you reminded me that I have to finish translating my Persona 4 review. Thanks for giving me YET ANOTHER thing to do

zexen wrote:Good, you reminded me that I have to finish translating my Persona 4 review. Thanks for giving me YET ANOTHER thing to do

I have a feeling Gears of war 2 won't stay on top too long...

pichu wrote:

zexen wrote:Good, you reminded me that I have to finish translating my Persona 4 review. Thanks for giving me YET ANOTHER thing to do

I have a feeling Gears of war 2 won't stay on top too long...

If it were for me, I'd give the game a perfect 10, because it's what it deserves. Let's see...maybe

we need a copy editor here.... too many high scorezzz

Don Ramón wrote:we need a copy editor here.... too many high scorezzz

We'll hire Falcon. Right?

Me what???

I wonder what will be the first game to get a perfect 10?

Brute wrote:I wonder what will be the first game to get a perfect 10?

If we put that on the hands of pichu it could wind up being..... Cooking mama

Pichu is the only person who plays games that are under an 8. JK

I doubt we will see any 10's unless someone does a past review, and I don't think anyone around here would give any games other then GTA4 and Ocarina a 10. I don't think we will see a GTA4 review though as that has been argued to death.

You know what that could be an interesting thread, I think I will start it best bet for a 10 (in the future)

I'm wondering if I should give P4 a 10 (when I finish translating the review, that is). For me it's a 10, but I also criticized some very minor things in the review. Though I wanna be consistent.

But no, on aggregated, no game will EVER score a ten. Heck, OoT everyone says it's a perfect 10 and for me it's barely an 8

The thing is, we only review good games, lol

zexen wrote:I'm wondering if I should give P4 a 10 (when I finish translating the review, that is). For me it's a 10, but I also criticized some very minor things in the review. Though I wanna be consistent.

But no, on aggregated, no game will EVER score a ten. Heck, OoT everyone says it's a perfect 10 and for me it's barely an 8

Well I tend to like Roger Eberts theroy of reviewing something based on what it is.

Roger Ebert wrote:When you ask a friend if Hellboy is any good, you're not asking if it's any good compared to Mystic River, you're asking if it's any good compared to The Punisher. And my answer would be, on a scale of one to four, if Superman is four, then Hellboy is three and The Punisher is two. In the same way, if American Beauty gets four stars, then (The United States of) Leland clocks in at about two

In essence a 10 for Smash Bros. does not mean its better then Bioshock at a 9. I think that is the best system to use around here.

In my mind

9-10 is a must by for that genre not console
8-9 is something you should get
7-8 is something you should get if you really like that genre
6-7 is something you may find good if your really like that genre
5-6 is something that is a throw away but if you really love this type of game, its barable
4-5 is something you most likley will not enjoy but has some sparkles of life
3-4 is far from fun but if for some reason you are compelled
2-3 is not worth buying
1-2 do not by this game
0-1 this is so bad you might get it for the laughs